Music
&
Nightlife
Live Music
Live Music
Live Music

Cheap(er) Boat Rentals in Central Ohio: The Budget Lake Day Guide

Adventure, Family Friendly, Getaway, Seasonal, Sports, Things to Do

Photo courtesy of Deer Creek Lodge Marina

Summer in Columbus means one thing on repeat: everybody wants to be on a lake. The problem is that owning a boat costs about as much as a second mortgage, and most of us just want one good day on the water, not a slip fee.

Good news. You don’t need to own a boat to have a lake day. You just need to know where to look, and Central Ohio has more affordable rental spots than you’d think, all within an hour or so of downtown.

We pulled real prices from the marinas themselves so you can actually plan a budget instead of guessing. Here’s where to go, what it costs, and how far you’re driving.

Cheap Boat Rentals in Columbus and Central Ohio

Alum Creek Marina | Delaware, OH

3615 S Old State Road, Delaware, OH 43015

Alum Creek is the move if you want the least driving and the best prices in one package. The marina sits inside Alum Creek State Park and is about 25 minutes from Columbus, no interstate slog required.

This is genuinely the budget champion of the bunch. A 3-person fishing boat runs $35/hour on weekdays ($40 on weekends), and a 4-person pontoon starts at $55/hour on weekdays ($65 on weekends). If your crew is bigger, a 10-person pontoon runs $100/hour weekdays. Kayaks, canoes, and SUPs are also available; call ahead since availability moves fast in summer.

A few things to know before you go: renters must be 21 or older, weekday rentals have a 2-hour minimum (3 hours on weekends), and prices don’t include gas or tax. Anyone born after January 1, 1982 needs to pass a quick 10-question boater exam, which the marina can walk you through.

More info here.

Photo courtesy of Alum Creek Marina

Hoover Adventures at Hoover Reservoir | Westerville, OH

If your idea of a lake day is quieter water and a kayak instead of an engine, Hoover Reservoir is the closest option to Columbus proper, easily reachable in 20 to 25 minutes from most parts of the city.

Hoover Adventures rents 10-foot kayaks starting at $30 for one hour, $55 for two hours, and $80 for three. A 3-hour canoe for up to three people runs $135. Worth noting: Hoover Reservoir has a 10-horsepower limit and no towed watersports, so this is strictly a paddling lake, not a pontoon-and-tube kind of day. That’s actually part of the appeal if you want something mellow.

Note, there is no single storefront address. Hoover Adventures launches from Hoover Reservoir’s public boat ramps, including Oxbow Boat Ramp (8401 Oxbow Rd, Westerville, OH 43082), Twin Bridges Boat Ramp (4748 Red Bank Rd, Galena, OH 43021), and Red Bank Boat Ramp (Sunbury Rd, Westerville, OH 43082).

More info here.

Photo courtesy of Hoover Adventures

Stop Googling “things to do this weekend.”

We’ve already done it for you.

Get the best of Central Ohio delivered daily.

👉 Sign up for the free Step Out Columbus newsletter.


Deer Creek Lake | Mount Sterling, OH

21001 Deer Creek Rd, Mount Sterling, OH 43143

Deer Creek is the closest full-power boating option south of the city, about 30 to 35 minutes from Columbus. Deer Creek Marina rents pontoon, jet, and fishing boats. The 10/11 passenger Tritoon comes with a 2-hour minimum around $200/hour on the weekends, plus a refundable $500 damage deposit.

If you want to really go all in, the 16 passenger Tritoon is $200 an hour on weekdays and $300 an hour on weekends. If you want to keep it reeeeeeally cheap, Deer Creek Lake has kayak rentals starting at $15 an hour and paddle boards starting at just $12 an hour.

It’s not the cheapest name on this list when it comes to powerboats, but it’s a solid middle-ground pick if Alum Creek’s smaller boats don’t fit your group and you don’t want to drive all the way to Buckeye Lake or Indian Lake.

More info here.

Photo courtesy of Deer Creek Lodge Marina

Buckeye Lake Boat Rental | Thornville, OH

15396 Township Rd 403, Thornville, OH 43076

Buckeye Lake is about 45 minutes east of Columbus and has become one of the go-to lake towns for a reason, including a rental shop that keeps its kayak prices genuinely cheap. A single sit-in kayak starts at $20, a fishing kayak at $25, and a 2-person kayak at $30, all with hourly or full-day options.

For groups who want a pontoon, a 14-foot pontoon starts at $175 and a 20 or 24-foot pontoon (up to 8 people) starts at $195, both bookable anywhere from 2 to 12 hours. Split that across a group of friends and it lands in the same range as a round of drinks and appetizers, except you get a whole day on the water out of it. Bonus points if you stop at Buckeye Lake Brewery or The Dirty Oar afterwards!

More info here.

Photo courtesy of Buckeye Lake Boat Rental

Indian Lake Pontoon Rentals at Indian Lake | Russells Point, OH

8121 OH-366, Russells Point, OH 43348

Indian Lake is the farthest drive on this list, about an hour and a half from Columbus, but it’s worth the trip for groups chasing the best pontoon-per-dollar. Skip the pricier marina options and go with Indian Lake Pontoon Rentals, which advertises itself as the best-priced pontoon fleet on the lake.

A 20 to 24-foot cruising pontoon runs $199 for a half day (4 hours) Monday through Thursday, or $289 for a full day. Weekend half-day rentals are $229, full day $329. They also run rotating specials, like a Sunday flat rate and Monday discounts, so it’s worth texting to ask what’s currently available before you book.

More info here.

Peer-to-Peer Options (Proceed With a Little Caution)

If none of the marinas above have what you’re looking for, or you’d rather rent directly from a private boat owner, sites like Boatsetter and GetMyBoat list boats around Columbus and Central Ohio too. Boatsetter shows Columbus listings starting around $60/hour for pontoons and party boats, with some Ohio-wide listings as low as $35/hour. GetMyBoat’s Columbus listings tend to start closer to $70/hour.

Here’s the disclaimer: these are peer-to-peer rentals, not marinas. Every boat is owned and listed by a different person, so pricing, boat condition, insurance coverage, and communication all vary from listing to listing. Some come with a captain included, some don’t, and cancellation policies change owner to owner. Read the individual listing carefully, check reviews, and confirm details directly with the owner before you book. Treat these as a backup option, not the first place to look.

The Budget Breakdown

If you want the cheapest possible day on the water with minimal drive time, Alum Creek Marina wins on both counts. If your crew wants a pontoon without owning one and doesn’t mind a longer drive, Indian Lake Pontoon Rentals stretches your money the furthest for a full day. And if paddling over powerboating sounds like your speed, Hoover Reservoir is sitting right in your backyard.

Whichever lake you pick, call ahead before you drive out. Prices, availability, and rules like boater education requirements can shift week to week during peak season, and marinas would rather answer a quick question than turn you away at the dock.

Now go get on the water. Your budget (and your farmers tan line) will thank you.

Did we miss one? Did one of these places close? Send us a note!

Summer Guides


Want to be the friend who always knows what’s going on?

Our free daily newsletter drops the best things to do, eat, and explore around Central Ohio straight into your inbox. No digging required.

👉 Sign up here and start looking like a genius.


Subscribe to our Newsletter

Step Out Columbus Newsletter Sign Up
Subscribe for our marketing and business newsletter too!

Connect with Columbus

Submit an Event

List a Business

 

X
To save to your favorites you must login first.
Login Here
X
You must be logged in to use this feature.