
Forget the jump scares at haunted attractions (Well, don’t forget about them completely). But just know, true fear comes from what we can’t understand, and while the creepiest places in Columbus come with real history, what they’ve left behind are inexplicable.
Think deadly fires, forgotten graves, murders, and more, leaving us with disembodied voices and apparitions disappearing into the night.
If you’re new here, Step Out Columbus is your friendly destination for discovering the best food, drinks, and things to do in Columbus and Central Ohio. So we dug into the paper trail behind five local spots with a dark past. Here are the 5 spots where you can feel the energy shift from normal into unsteady in the blink of an eye.
Want more hidden Columbus history? Follow us on Instagram and Facebook for more local finds.
The Creepiest Places is Columbus, Ohio
1. The Ohio State Hospital For the Insane (That Was Once the Biggest Building in America)
Where: West Broad Street, Hilltop inside Glenview Park, 2400 Glenview Blvd, Columbus, OH 43204
In 1838, Ohio opened its first state asylum on East Broad Street, about a mile from the Statehouse. On November 18, 1868, a fire started in a clothing room. Six female patients died from the smoke.
The state rebuilt on 300 acres along West Broad Street in what is now known as the Hilltop. The new hospital opened in 1877 and cost about $1.5 million. According to the Ohio History Connection, it was the largest building under one roof in the U.S. until the Pentagon went up in the 1940s. Not to make a cheap pun, but that’s insane.
It was built for about 850 patients. By 1935, it held nearly 3,000. And sadly, the abuse and mistreatment of patients didn’t end there. Frequent therapies utilized in the hospital, many of which were considered the best options at the time, included lobotomies, electroshock therapy, and others.
The building was torn down in 1991. State offices for Ohio Department of Transportation and the Ohio Department of Public Safety now sit on the land… yet some eerie remnants still reside there to this day…
What’s left: The building is gone. The graves are not. Hospital cemeteries still sit on the grounds, with many gravestones showing nothing more than a number. The most infamous gravestone onsite, however, simply says “Specimens.”
Freaky.

2. The Gates of Hell
Where: The Glen Echo ravine, where the creek runs under North High Street
Hidden in a unique wooded ravine under the city, The Gates of Hell sit ominously. Some also call the spot the Portal to Hell or the Blood Bowl. Its mouth is covered in graffiti, and a giant cage of steel beams guards the entrance.
That cage isn’t just there to keep demons in. It keeps trees and debris from clogging the drain, but that’s not as creepy tbh. The tunnel carries a stream from Glen Echo Park under High Street toward the Olentangy River. Part of it is built from old sandstone blocks, likely from the Marble Cliff Quarry over across the Scioto River.
The story goes that a skateboarder died on the tunnel’s steep walls in the 1980s, which gave it the “Blood Bowl” name. There’s no official record of that happening, so the more likely origin is the amount of skaters that have taken nasty spills on that concrete.
One more thing: the tunnel is technically off limits, and it can flood after rain. Check it out from the ravine and leave the exploring to the legends (and the ghosts).
Like knowing the real story behind local legends? Sign up for the Step Out Columbus newsletter to get the best things to do in Columbus sent right to your inbox.

3. Char Bar
439 N High St, Short North/Arena District
Char Bar is a longtime dive bar known for its super cheap drinks and friendly atmosphere. It also sits in a building that went up before the Civil War and worked as a funeral parlor until the early 1900s. The bar’s lower level used to be the main floor before High Street was raised, which is where many rumors have circulated that Abe Lincoln got a touch-up while his funeral procession rode through town. Read more in our full Char Bar deep dive.
Staff and regulars have stories, many featuring the broken piano in the basement that plays itself late at night, along with disembodied voices and footsteps. Some have even reported seeing a devilish figure in the tunnel (which is now occupied by a skeleton).

4. Ringside Cafe
19 N. Pearl St, Downtown Columbus
Tucked in an alley a hop, skip, and a jump from the Statehouse, Ringside has been pouring drinks since 1897. It opened as the Board of Trade Saloon, burned down in 1909, and came back in 1910 as the Chamber of Commerce Cafe & Rathskeller. During Prohibition, it went by the Jolly Gargoyle. It became Ringside in the 1930s.
Politicians have been walking over from the Statehouse for more than a century, yet the rumors about how the politicians got there (and what they did while they were there) are still up in the air. The stained glass windows still show a Democratic donkey and a Republican elephant, a remnant from the days when the cafe’s owner would light up the window of whichever party was in power.
The rumors run deep here. People say it hosted underground prizefights in the basement, home to a few untimely deaths in the meantime. Ghost stories include a tall man in a coat and hat who roams at night, plus the voices of women and children who may have been gambled away after a fight didn’t go their way. Some swear Clem, who ran the place from the 1960s until he died in 1993, still sits in the first booth where he used to smoke cigars.
One of the biggest rumors is that there was an underground tunnel that ran from Ringside to the Statehouse, allowing politicians to sneak away from work to broker shady deals and get their buzz on. But the 1910 building, the stained glass, and more than a century of Statehouse regulars are all real. So is the 1.5-pound Buster Douglas burger.

5. Thurber House
77 Jefferson Ave, just east of downtown
Remember the asylum fire from No. 1? This 1873 house sits on land that was once part of those asylum grounds. Columbus writer James Thurber lived here from 1913 to 1917, while he was a student at Ohio State.
On November 17, 1915, Thurber heard footsteps downstairs when no one was there. He later turned that night into his short story “The Night the Ghost Got In.”
He played it for laughs. By the end of the story, his mother throws a shoe through the neighbor’s window and his grandfather shoots a police officer. But Thurber believed in that ghost for the rest of his life. One of those “haha remember that? That was crazy and totally NOT scary” experiences.
The house has another death on record. In 1904, a jeweler named Thomas Tracy Tress shot himself in an upstairs bedroom while trying to show that a revolver wasn’t loaded… or so they say…
Now: You can sign up for paranormal investigations and ghost tours here.

See the Real Spooky Side of Columbus
These five spots prove the scariest stories are the ones with a paper trail. Save this list for your next spooky night out, and send it to the friend who always asks “but is that actually true?”
Then follow @stepoutcolumbus for more hidden Columbus history.


