Not every restaurant in Columbus will just seat you. Some make you plan weeks out, others months. One won’t even tell you the address until you’ve already booked.
If you’re new here, welcome! Step Out Columbus is the leading destination for the best food, drinks, and things to do in Columbus and Central Ohio, and we’ve spent real time (and made more than a few humbling phone calls) tracking down the toughest tables in town.
If you’re planning a special occasion dinner and want the meal to feel like an actual event, these are the 5 most exclusive restaurant reservations in Central Ohio, plus exactly how far ahead you need to book each one so you’re not left standing at the door.
The Most Exclusive Restaurant Reservations in Columbus and Central Ohio
Hillcrest Supper Club: You Won’t Even Know Where You’re Eating
Hillcrest Supper Club might be the single hardest reservation in Central Ohio, and it’s barely a restaurant in the traditional sense. Chef Joey Lyons hosts multi course dinners out of his own German Village apartment, and you won’t find a website, a phone number, or even an address until you’ve already booked a seat.
Every dinner seats around 10 guests, runs seven plus courses (often with a few surprise courses thrown in), and sells out completely. Every single time.
The only way in is to grab your ticket through their online store the moment a new date drops. Seats disappear fast, so if you’re serious about scoring one, follow along closely and be ready to book the second something opens up.
If you strike out, German Village won’t leave you hungry while you wait for your shot. Barcelona, Cento, and Lindey’s are all a short walk from wherever that night’s dinner happens to be.
Lola & Giuseppe’s Trattoria: Plan on Booking Months Out
Lola & Giuseppe’s Trattoria in Gahanna has earned a reputation that borders on legend, and we can vouch for it firsthand. We once walked into this Granville Street trattoria on a Friday night without a reservation, hoping for a table for two. They politely informed us they were booked solid for the next two weeks.
Lesson learned. When we finally got a seat, it lived up to the hype and then some, and the carrot cake alone is worth the wait. Do not plan on walking in on a weekend without calling ahead first, and if you want a table on a Friday or Saturday, book months in advance.
Want to know the second a new hot spot lands on our radar? Subscribe to our free daily newsletter so you can discover all the hottest food & drink intel like this in real time.
Gahanna has plenty to keep you fed while your reservation date rolls around. High Bank Distillery Co., Three Creeks Kitchen + Cocktails, and Cap City Fine Diner and Bar are all worth a visit in the meantime.
Pasqualone’s Ristorante: The Columbus Italian Spot You’ve Probably Never Heard Of
Tucked into an unassuming plaza on Columbus’s northeast side, Pasqualone’s Ristorante seats a little over two dozen people, and owners David and Lori Pasqualone keep it that way on purpose. The Abruzzi inspired menu, think veal meatballs stuffed with mozzarella and capicola, plus a veal loaf built with spinach, provolone, and prosciutto, is worth the wait. But there is absolutely a wait.
Reservations here typically need to be made weeks in advance, and the restaurant only seats guests Wednesday through Saturday evenings. We wrote a full breakdown of why this place is worth the hunt right here.
Pasqualone’s keeps a low profile, so it’s not surrounded by a big dining scene, though the Brazilian Grill & Bakery is right next door (shout out to Columbus Food Adventures‘ Alt Eats tour for introducing us to this spot). Uptown Westerville is also just a few minutes away if you want a backup plan or a pre-dinner drink while you wait on your reservation date.
Haru Omakase: Six Seats, One Chef, No Room for Error
Haru Omakase’s main dining room is a reliable bet most nights if you’re craving one of Central Ohio’s best sushi experiences. But the real prize is the chef’s counter, where executive chef Yudi Makassau serves an intimate, ever changing omakase menu to just six people at a time.
Counter seats run around $89 to $99 per person depending on the night, and the menu rotates roughly every six weeks, so no two visits look quite the same. With only six spots available on any given night and serious demand for them, book the moment a date opens up instead of waiting until the week you actually want to go.
Curious how we find spots like this before everyone else does? Our newsletter is basically built for that. Subscribe here and we’ll keep you looped in on Columbus’s best, and hardest to get, tables.
If the counter is full, Polaris has solid backup options nearby, including Eddie Merlot’s and Mitchell’s Steakhouse, for a similarly special occasion feel.
Elevator Brewery & Draught Haus: The Secret Balcony Almost Nobody Books
This last one is less about scarcity and more about knowing it exists. Inside the historic Columbia Larrimer Building downtown, a building with its own haunted backstory involving a rowdy early 1900s billiards hall, Elevator Brewery & Draught Haus has a private balcony table tucked above the main dining room.
We covered the full haunted history (and the food) right here, but the short version is this: call ahead and ask for the balcony specifically. It’s not guaranteed, and it’s definitely not something you’ll stumble into by walking in and requesting a table.
Downtown and the Short North are right outside the door, so if the balcony’s booked, Jeff Ruby’s Steakhouse, The Pearl, and Marcella’s are all worth exploring instead.
How Far Ahead You Actually Need to Book
Here’s the cheat sheet for planning your next special occasion dinner around one of Central Ohio’s most exclusive restaurant reservations:
- Hillcrest Supper Club: The moment a new date is announced. Every dinner sells out.
- Lola & Giuseppe’s Trattoria: At least one month in advance, especially for weekend seating.
- Pasqualone’s Ristorante: Weeks in advance for any night they’re open.
- Haru Omakase (chef’s counter): As soon as new dates open. Only six seats a night.
- Elevator Brewery’s balcony: Call ahead and ask specifically. First come, first served by phone.
Central Ohio’s best tables don’t come easy, and honestly, that’s kind of the point. Save this guide before your next special occasion sneaks up on you, because these reservations vanish fast. And if you manage to snag a seat at any of these five, tag us on Instagram so we can see it too!
