Music
&
Nightlife
Live Music
Live Music
Live Music

Columbus Pizza Legend Closes After 30 Years — But Another Local Legend Is Already Taking Over

Eat & Drink, Food & Drink News

logo-buf-600w
Written by Step Out Columbus
Published on May 16, 2025
Photo courtesy of Sparano’s Pizza

If you grew up on the west side of Columbus, chances are you’ve got a Sparano’s Pizza memory or two. For so many, it was the Friday night staple with the family.

Either way, it’s officially the end of an era… Sparano’s Pizza has closed its doors after 30 years in business.

The news came as a surprise to longtime customers, with the closure announced suddenly and effective immediately. But in a rare twist that doesn’t leave us crying into our crusts, there’s already a new plan already in motion, and it’s a pretty solid one.

The Goodbye (And the Good News)

In a heartfelt message posted online, the owners of Sparano’s shared their gratitude:

“We are very fortunate to have been surrounded by you all, and could not have been successful without you. We are pleased to announce that Sparano’s Pizza is ‘passing the pepperoni’ to Cappy’s Pizza, effective immediately.”

Yes, you read that right. Cappy’s Pizza, another longtime local favorite in London that’s been slinging pies for over 50 years, is taking over the location at 3947 West Broad Street. They’ll be keeping the same phone number and continuing service right where Sparano’s left off.

In other words: the lights are staying on, the ovens are staying hot, and your pizza cravings are still in good hands.

Photo courtesy of Slice

A New Chapter for a West Side Classic

While we’ll miss Sparano’s and their buttery crust, generous toppings, and no-frills charm, it’s hard to be too sad knowing that Cappy’s is stepping in. The team at Cappy’s is excited to expand into the west side, and it sounds like they’re planning to keep the community-first spirit alive.

So whether you’re a Sparano’s loyalist or a longtime Cappy’s fan, go grab a slice soon. Let’s support the local legends who keep our pizza traditions alive, and hopefully make some new memories along the way.

Photo courtesy of Sparano’s Pizza

Food & Drink News

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Step Out Columbus Newsletter Sign Up
Subscribe for our marketing and business newsletter too!

Connect with Columbus

Submit an Event

List a Business

 

Find More ➭ Pizza
X
To save to your favorites you must login first.
Login Here
X
You must be logged in to use this feature.