Music
&
Nightlife
Live Music
Live Music

Foldable New York Pizza, Fresh-Filled Cannolis & Game Day Buffets? This Columbus Spot Does It All

Beer, Drink, Eat & Drink

logo-buf-600w
Written by Step Out Columbus
Published on March 10, 2026

This article is a paid promotion sponsored by an SOC advertiser and designed to share valuable info with our readers.

Borgata Pizza Cafe / Photo x Hannah Shoemaker for Step Out Columbus

Looking for your next go-to Italian spot? Found it. Borgata Pizza Cafe is the answer — whether you’re planning date night, rolling in with the family, or staking out a table for game day. 

First things first: if they serve it, they make it  — from scratch. The hearty meatballs. The spicy sausage. The perfectly-cooked pasta. Even the salad dressings and garlic butter are freshly made in-house. And with a certified chef in the kitchen, it’s all extra dialed-in. 

Borgata Pizza Cafe / Photo x Hannah Shoemaker for Step Out Columbus

We would say that the pizza is the star of the show here — after all, it’s in the name. And yes, the pizza deserves its own moment. We love that you can get it by the slice, but trust us…you’re gonna want more than just one. This is classic New York–style pizza — the kind you fold in half and immediately want another slice of. They even drop a monthly specialty pizza, so keep an eye on their socials if you want in.

Borgata Pizza Cafe / Photo x Hannah Shoemaker for Step Out Columbus

But they’re about so much more than the fantastic pizza here. The lasagna, spicy sausage-stuffed peppers, and housemade meatballs have all built loyal fan clubs. They also just added a Caesar salad to the menu, made with hydroponic lettuce for max freshness and sustainability.  

Make sure you save room for dessert too, because every cannoli is filled to order. Yep, you read that right. No soggy shells here. They rotate seasonal flavors monthly, and you can even grab a DIY cannoli kit to bring the fun home. (Dinner party flex unlocked.)

Borgata Pizza Cafe / Photo x Abigail Reeder for Step Out Columbus

But what really sets this place apart? The community focus. They partner with the Dublin Schools Pax Program to provide jobs for students with special needs. They also offer first responder and military discounts and donate team meals to local football teams.

If you’re a Buckeye fan, you’re gonna want to be here on game days. It’s a lively, everyone-cheering-together vibe. Plus, they serve a game-day buffet with all-you-can-eat pizza, wings, salad, and more. Yeah, it’s the kind of place you post up for the whole afternoon. So you can finally put to bed the questions of where to go and what to eat on game days. 

Borgata Pizza Cafe / Photo x Hannah Shoemaker for Step Out Columbus

No game on? You’ve still got happy hour Monday–Saturday (3-6 pm), wine Wednesdays with half-price bottles, and lunch specials for you lucky ducks who work nearby. With lunch specials starting at just $10.99, you can’t afford to miss out. 

And mark your calendars, because the family-friendly (that includes furry family) patio is set to open in March around St. Patrick’s Day — weather permitting. Translation: sunshine, pizza, and maybe a green beer moment.

Basically? Whether you’re here for a foldable slice or a full-on Buckeye watch party, this is the kind of place that quickly becomes your spot. So go hungry. And make sure to order extra cannolis. 

Check out Borgata Pizza Cafe here!

Full Service

Borgata Pizza Cafe

2285 West Dublin-Granville Road Worthington, OH 43085 • $$$$$

Other

New York Style, Hand Tossed Pizza. Homemade Spaghetti and Meatballs, we make our own noodles, sauce, meatballs right here on site. Sandwiches, Chicken ...

  • Take-out
  • No Reservations
  • Accepts Credit Cards
  • Offers Catering
  • Good for Groups
  • Family Friendly
  • Wait Service
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • TV
  • Bike Parking

This article is a paid promotion sponsored by an SOC advertiser and designed to share valuable info with our readers.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Step Out Columbus Newsletter Sign Up
Subscribe for our marketing and business newsletter too!

Connect with Columbus

Submit an Event

List a Business

 

Find More ➭ Sponsored Content
X
To save to your favorites you must login first.
Login Here
X
You must be logged in to use this feature.