There’s a chill in the air and sweaters are making a comeback… you know what that means: It’s officially time to switch from iced coffee mode to full-on fall flavors galore.
While pumpkin spice lattes (or as the cool kids call it, PSL) are still the reigning champs of seasonal drinks, there’s a whole world of cozy, autumn-inspired coffees waiting to warm your hands and your heart.
Luckily, Columbus and Central Ohio are home to some seriously great spots that are ready to fill your cup with autumn goodness. Whether you’re after that iconic PSL or something a little different, here’s your guide to sipping your way through the season.
One Line Coffee
41 South High St, Columbus, Ohio 43215
471 West Rich St, Columbus, Ohio 43215
745 North High St, Columbus, Ohio 43215
Cozy vibes? Check. Delicious local ingredients? Double check. One Line Coffee’s pumpkin spice latte is everything you want for fall in a 12 or 16 oz cup—pure coziness. But wait, there’s more! They’ve got the Milligan’s Maple Latte, made with locally-sourced maple syrup from Milligan’s in Amesville, OH, and the Honey Latte, featuring honey from Honeyrun Farm in Williamsport, OH. Ohio fall flavors don’t get more authentic than this.
Roosevelt Coffee House
300 E Long St, Columbus, OH 43215
462 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43215
2374 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43204
If you’re looking for seasonal flavors galore, Roosevelt Coffee House has them in spades. Not only can you add pumpkin flavor to pretty much any drink (yep, that means PSLs), but you’d be missing out if you didn’t try their S’mortado: a cortado rimmed with chocolate sauce and graham cracker crumble, topped with toasted marshmallows. It’s basically a campfire in a cup. And for something a little extra cozy, the Cinnamon Roll Cappuccino and Chaider (a chai and apple cider combo) will make you wish fall lasted forever.
Stonebrick Café
999 Bethel Rd # D, Columbus, OH 43214
This cozy little coffee shop has fall flavors so good, you’ll be tempted to try them all. Teddy Bear (maple and honey), White Pumpkin (white mocha and pumpkin), and even the Football Season (candied orange syrup with chocolate drizzle) are all super fall-coded. Want something extra unique? Go for the Alex (caramel apple butter and caramel drizzle) or the Shmores. Fall just hit a new flavor level.
Coffee Connections of Hilliard
4004 Main St, Hilliard, OH 43026
5354 Center St, Hilliard, OH 43026
Coffee Connections keeps things festive with their Dirty Chais, hot chocolates, and spiced ciders, but the real stars of the season are their house-made syrups. You’ll be drooling over flavors like Brown Sugar Cinnamon, Cinnamon Roll, French Toast, and Buckeye. Whatever drink you choose, you can bet your bottom dollar that it’ll taste like fall in a cup.
Stauf’s Coffee Roasters
1277 Grandview Ave, Columbus, OH 43212
627 S. 3rd St, Columbus, OH 43206
1334 Neil Ave, Columbus, Ohio 43201
59 Spruce St, Columbus, OH 43215 (North Market)
Picking a flavor at Stauf’s is an ordeal (in the best way). They’ve got Pumpkin Spice, Mocha S’mores, Fireside Bliss, Butter Rum… you name it, they got it. It’s one of those places where you can walk in and know that whatever you pick, it’s going to be good. Stressful in the best way possible.
Porter’s Coffee House and Bakery
194 W Church St, Pickerington, OH 43147
201 Clint Dr # 100, Pickerington, OH 43147
Pumpkin spice lovers, rejoice—Porter’s has you covered with their PSL made with real pumpkin. But don’t stop there. Their Cinderella Pumpkin, S’mores, Toasted Marshmallow, Apple Crisp Chai, and Caramel Apple Pie flavors will have you wishing fall would never end. Honestly, just get one of everything. We won’t judge.
The Coffee Vault
9, W Columbus St, Galena, OH 43021
The Coffee Vault has fall coffee down to a science (maybe it’s all that former-bank-turned-coffee-shop magic). Their upside-down iced pumpkin pancake latte, topped with pumpkin spice cold foam, is an absolute game changer. If you’re looking for fall flavors with a twist, this is your spot.
Coffee Underground
2141 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH 43201
Aside from the delicious house-made pumpkin spice syrup, Coffee Underground offers caramel apple cider and an Apple Pie à la Mode drink that’s essentially dessert in a cup. Plus, it’s a no-obligation space where you can hang out, study, or just chill with a drink. It’s as cozy as it gets.
Closing Thoughts (We Know… There’s a Latte to Love Here)
Whether you’re a PSL purist or a fan of unique seasonal flavors like maple, caramel apple butter, or s’mores, these coffee spots in Columbus and Central Ohio are brewing up all the fall vibes. Grab a friend, throw on your coziest sweater, and head out to taste the season. After all, fall isn’t really fall without a cozy drink in hand.
Did we miss one? Did one of these places close? Send us a note!
